Efficacy and safety of Phlogenzym - a protease formulation, in sepsis in children
Shahid S.K.1 Turakhia N.H. 2 Kundra M. 1, Shanbag P. 1, Daftary G.V. 2 Schiess W. 3
1
LTMMC and LTMG Hospital & Medical College,
Mumbai
2 SIRO
Research Foundation, Mumbai
3 Mucos Pharma GmbH, Geretsried,
Germany
J
Assoc Physicians India (JAPI) 2002, Vol. 50, pp. 527-531
Abstract
Infections
are a major cause of hospitalisation wherein the host mounts an inflammatory
response against the infecting
agent. Administration of proteolytic enzymes could regulate the host's immune
system and help early recovery from sepsis.
The aim of the study was to test
the efficacy and safety of an oral enzyme formulation, Phlogenzym (Mucos Pharma
GmbH, Geretsried, Germany; constituents of each enteric - coated tablet were
bromelain 90 mg, trypsin 48 mg, rutin 100 mg) as adjuvant therapy in treatment
of sepsis in children.
Double-blind,
randomised, controlled phase III study at a tertiary care center was performed
wherein 60 eligible children aged one month to 12 years with sepsis were
included. Detailed history, complete clinical evaluation
including the modified Glasgow coma scale score, haemogram, bacterial culture,
metabolic work up, liver and renal biochemistry were done in all cases.
Cerebrospinal fluid analysis, urine analysis, radiological and other tests were
done as and when needed to aid in diagnosis. Patients were randomised
to receive either Phlogenzym (n=30; 17 boys) or placebo (n=30; 22 boys) tablets
(1 tablet / 10 kg body weight up to maximum six tablets a day in two or three
divided doses for 14-21 days) along with appropriate antibiotics and supportive
treatment. As the children were small and had altered conscious level, the
tablets were crushed, mixed with ample water and given via an indwelling
nasogastric tube and orally when the child was fully conscious. Duration of
treatment depended on the site and severity of infection. For children less than
three months old, antibiotic combination used was ampicillin and gentamicin or
cefotaxime and gentamicin or amikacin. Antibiotic combinations given to children
older than three months were ampicillin and chloromycetin or ampicillin and
cloxacillin and chloromycetin or cefotaxime and amikacin depending on the
infecting agent and the severity of infection. Fourteen patients (six in
Phlogenzym group) received dexamethasone in the first 3-5 days of the illness
and five cases (two from Phlogenzym group) received phenobarbitone.
Median time taken for fever to subside was three days (range 1-12; 95% Cl - 1.14
to 7.14) in the Phlogenzym group vs four days (range 1-18; 95% Cl - 3.52 to
11.52) in the placebo group (p < 0.05); haemodynamic support was needed for
two days (range 1-3; 95% Cl - 0.84 to 3.16) in the Phlogenzym group but three
days (range 1-8; 95% Cl 0.76 to 5.24) in the placebo group (p < 0.05). The
modified Glasgow coma scale score normalized in three days (range 1-14; 95% Cl
4.62 to 9.62) in the Phlogenzym group vs 5.5 days (range 1-18; 95% Cl - 2.52 to
13.52) in the placebo group (p > 0.05). Oral feeds could be started in four
days (range 1-15; 95% Cl - 1.74 to 9.74) in the Phlogenzym group vs five days (range
1-11; 95% Cl - 1.26 to 11.26) in the placebo group (p > 0.05). Two patients
died in the placebo group.
Patients in the study being very young and altered due to their illness had to
be given crushed tablets. Gastric juice tends to dilute the enzymatic activity
and this could have reduced efficacy of Phlogenzym. Fourteen patients (six
in the Phlogenzym group) received dexamethasone which being immuno-suppressive
would interfere with the enzyme functions. Nonetheless, the study suggests that
enzymes have a place as an adjuvant with
antibiotics and supportive treatment for early improvement of pediatric patients
with sepsis.